Search
  • Our People
    • View everyone
  • What we do
    Private Wealth
    • Art and Cultural Property
    • Entrepreneurs and family businesses
    • Non contentious probate
    • Philanthropy and charities
    • Taxation for international clients
    • Trusts in a commercial context
    • Wills and Estate Planning
    Immigration
    • Corporate Immigration
    • Work in the UK
    • Visit the UK
    • Live permanently in the UK
    • Study in the UK
    • Family in the UK
    • The UK and Europe
    • Entrepreneurs and Global Talent
    Dispute resolution
    • Contentious trusts and probate
    • Family governance and disharmony
    • MTG Resolution
    Real Estate
  • About us
    • About us
    • News
  • What we think
  • Careers
  • Contact us
RESOLUTION
RECOMMENDS
Home / In Brief / Enforceability of a foreign oral Will in the BVI

5 April 2022

Enforceability of a foreign oral Will in the BVI

Rosalind Hetherington

test intro

The Eastern Caribbean Court of Appeal recently handed down an important judgment in the case of Al-Thani v Al Thani, permitting the enforcement of foreign oral wills in the BVI. Simon Goldring and Rosalind Hetherington were the instructing solicitors for the Respondents.

A member of the Qatari royal family died in 2014 while domiciled in Qatar. Following his death, an entry was discovered in the Sharia Court register having been made before and signed by a judge and issued by the Registry in Qatar back in 1990. Under Qatari law, such an entry is treated as a valid Will, although it is not signed by the testator. This entry recorded the deceased’s oral wishes regarding the disposition of his worldwide estate which included giving 20% of his movable and immovable estate to his sister, niece and “right hand man” (the Respondents).

The deceased’s widow, daughter and first son (the Appellants) initiated proceedings in the first instance court in Qatar challenging the validity and enforceability of the entry as a “Will” on the basis it had been revoked during the deceased’s lifetime. Shortly after issuing proceedings in Qatar, they also made an ex-parte application in the High Court of the Territory of the Virgin Islands for a grant of letters of administration of the deceased’s estate in the BVI which comprised shares in BVI companies. The application did not disclose the existence of the Qatari Will or that there were proceedings in Qatar challenging its validity. The High Court in the BVI granted letters of administration of the deceased’s estate in the BVI to the Appellants, on the basis that the deceased had died intestate.

Subsequently, the Qatari Court of Appeal, and the highest Qatari appellate court, the Court of Cassation, upheld the validity of the Qatari Will. The Respondents therefore brought proceedings in the BVI for the revocation of the letters of administration granted to the Appellants and for probate of the Qatari Will. The Appellants’ defence was that the Qatari Will was invalid under BVI law.

Following a trial of preliminary issues, it was held that: (1) The judgment of the Qatari Court of Appeal was valid and enforceable and conclusive as to the validity and enforceability of the Qatari Will in the BVI; (2) The Appellants are estopped by the judgment of the Qatari Court of Appeal from contending that the Qatari Will is not valid or enforceable in the BVI for the disposal of the deceased’s movable property in the BVI; (3) The deceased’s movable property in the BVI includes registered shares of various BVI companies. The Appellants proceeded to appeal.

The appeal was dismissed. The Court of Appeal confirmed the principles applicable to res judicata and issue estoppel and emphasised that the Qatari proceedings and the BVI proceedings were materially identical, and they ought not to be re-litigated. It found the Court of first instance was correct to find that the rules of the deceased’s domicile governed the validity of the Qatari Will.  The law of the deceased’s domicile applied to the succession of movable assets.  The Appellants had sought to argue that, by virtue of the provisions of section 245 of the BVI Business Companies Act 2004, shares were in fact immovable assets.  The Court of Appeal, making it’s first ruling on this issue, found that whilst section 245 deemed company shares to be located in the BVI for title purposes, they were still movable property for succession purposes.

The take-home message of these proceedings is that a foreign oral Will, found to be valid under the law of the deceased’s jurisdiction of domicile, is valid and enforceable in the BVI for the purposes of succession of the deceased’s movable property in the BVI, including registered shares in a BVI company.

Rosalind Hetherington

Senior Associate

+44 (0)20 7786 8733 rosalind.hetherington@mtgllp.com Download vCard↓

Rosalind Hetherington is a Senior Associate in Maurice Turnor Gardner’s dispute resolution team. She is recognised as a rising star in the contentious trusts industry.

Related articles

Naming rights for donations; how can charities mitigate the risks involved?

Read more
All articles
  • Our People
  • What we do
  • About us
  • What we think
  • Careers
  • Contact us
  • Sitemap
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Cookie policy
  • Interest policy
  • SRA transparency on fees
© 2023 Maurice Turnor Gardner LLP. All rights reserved
  • Linkedin
  • Twitter
Subscribe to the newsletter
Back to top↑

 

This website uses cookies to ensure the best possible user experience.

You can change the way cookies are used through your internet browser settings but can also update your preferences through settings.

For more information about cookies and the types of cookies we use please read our Cookies Policy.

MTG
Powered by  GDPR Cookie Compliance
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies to protect the security of the site and to ensure that we can provide the best possible user experience. Cookies are small text files that are placed on your computer in order to track activity.

Our website distinguishes between cookies that are strictly necessary for the effective operation of the site and those that are not, such as analytical or third party cookies. We will only place cookies without your explicit consent where they are strictly necessary.

For more information about the specific types of cookies used, please read our Cookies Policy.

Strictly Necessary Cookies

Strictly Necessary Cookie should be enabled at all times so that we can save your preferences for cookie settings.

If you disable this cookie, we will not be able to save your preferences. This means that every time you visit this website you will need to enable or disable cookies again.

Analytical cookies

This website uses Google Analytics to collect anonymous information such as the number of visitors to the site, and the most popular pages.

Keeping this cookie enabled helps us to improve our website.

Please enable Strictly Necessary Cookies first so that we can save your preferences!